3 Perfect Book Pairings for Fall: If You Liked That, Check This Out

There’s something about fall that makes readers want to cozy up with a good book. It might be the cooler nights, softer fabrics, or the changing leaves that create the perfect atmosphere for stories full of mystery, magic, and suspense. If you’ve ever finished a favorite and wondered what to pick up next, we’ve got you covered. These “if you liked this book, read that book” pairings highlight three of the best books to read this fall, from dark academia novels to cozy fantasy recommendations to edge-of-your-seat thrillers. You can find all of these recommendations in the shop.

🍂 If you liked: The Secret History by Donna Tartt✨ Check out: The Cloisters by Katy Hays

Donna Tartt’s The Secret History is often the first title that comes to mind when readers crave a dark academia book. It’s full of obsession, secrets, and the intoxicating pull of intellectual discovery. If that speaks to you, Katy Hays’ The Cloisters is your next must-read.

This atmospheric fall novel follows Ann Stilwell, a young woman who takes a summer job at The Cloisters, a Gothic museum in New York famous for its medieval art and mysterious reputation. When she uncovers a hidden deck of Renaissance tarot cards, Ann is drawn into a dangerous game of ambition, fate, and betrayal. Perfect for fans of haunting campus settings, art history mysteries, and gothic fall vibes, The Cloisters delivers a moody escape for long October nights.

🍂 If you liked: Legends & Lattes by Travis Baldree✨ Check out: The Enchanted Greenhouse by Sara Beth Durst

One of the reasons Legends & Lattes became a viral sensation is because it introduced readers to cozy fantasy books. Cozy fantasy is low stakes, heartwarming, and full of charm. If you’re craving more of that comfort this fall, Sara Beth Durst’s The Enchanted Greenhouse is the perfect pick.

The novel follows a woman who inherits a mysterious greenhouse overflowing with magical plants, each with enchanting (and sometimes mischievous) powers. As she learns to nurture the greenhouse, she also uncovers friendship, self-discovery, and a touch of romance. With its blend of magical plants, whimsical adventures, and found-family warmth, this book feels like a steaming mug of tea on a crisp autumn day. It’s the kind of feel-good fantasy book that will brighten your fall reading list.

🍂 If you liked: The Paris Apartment by Lucy Foley✨ Check out: With a Vengeance by Riley Sager 

Lucy Foley’s The Paris Apartment became an instant favorite for fans of locked-room mysteries and claustrophobic thrillers, a story where every character hides a secret and danger lurks behind every door. If you loved that mix of tension, atmosphere, and shocking twists, Riley Sager’s With a Vengeance is the perfect next read.

Sager’s latest novel follows a woman who narrowly survives a violent attack, only to find herself caught in a chilling aftermath where no one can be trusted. As she pieces together what really happened, paranoia builds, dark truths surface, and every answer only leads to more danger. With its blend of psychological suspense, unexpected twists, and moody fall atmosphere, With a Vengeance is one of the most unputdownable thrillers of 2025, perfect for fans of Lucy Foley’s brand of twisty suspense.

🍂 Build Your Perfect Fall TBR From dark academia mysteries to cozy fantasy escapes to page-turning thrillers, these books are made for fall reading. Stop by our store to pick up your copy and get ready for a season of unforgettable stories.